Why EIN-Based Business Credit Could Be the Startup Equalizer That Threatens Traditional Lending Practices

Leveraging PAYDEX and FICO SBSS, EIN-based business credit offers a lifeline to startups, but is it disrupting the status quo too much?

EIN-Based Business Credit and Its Role in Equalizing Startup Opportunities

Starting a business has always been challenging, but for underrepresented entrepreneurs, these challenges are often compounded by systemic barriers to credit and capital. Traditional lending practices have historically placed minority entrepreneurs at a disadvantage, limiting their access to the financial resources needed to grow their ventures. 

However, in recent years, the development of EIN-based business credit through systems like PAYDEX and FICO SBSS has emerged as a powerful equalizer. 

These credit-building tools allow new startups to create a distinct financial identity separate from the personal credit of their founders, offering a more equitable path to growth and success.

This article explores the intricacies of EIN-based business credit, its impact on startup businesses, and how leveraging this credit system can provide significant opportunities– especially for underrepresented entrepreneurs. 

We will delve into the workings of PAYDEX and FICO SBSS, the importance of separating business and personal credit, and the challenges that remain in the business credit ecosystem. By understanding and utilizing these tools, entrepreneurs can level the financial playing field and unlock the potential for long-term business success.

The Power of EIN-Based Business Credit

EIN-based business credit revolves around using an Employer Identification Number (EIN) to build credit specifically for a business. An EIN acts as the business's identifier with the IRS and is often compared to a Social Security number for individuals. With EIN-based business credit, startups can create a credit profile that stands independently of the founder's personal credit. This distinction is critical because it not only protects the owner's personal finances but also enhances the credibility and financial stability of the business.

Advantages of EIN-Based Credit

1. Protection of Personal Credit: One of the most significant benefits of EIN-based credit is that it shields personal credit scores from the ups and downs of business operations. Startups often go through periods of high risk and tying business expenses to personal credit can damage the owner’s credit score if the business experiences financial difficulties.

2. Improved Access to Credit: Many lenders and suppliers are more likely to extend favorable credit terms to businesses with a solid business credit profile, regardless of the owner's personal credit history. This can be especially advantageous for entrepreneurs who have faced challenges maintaining personal credit due to past financial issues or systemic inequities.

3. Building Credibility: Establishing an EIN-based credit profile signals to potential creditors and investors that the business is financially responsible and separate from the personal finances of the founder. This credibility can be critical in securing larger loans, negotiating better payment terms with suppliers and forming strong financial relationships.

4. Increased Opportunities for Underrepresented Founders: Minority entrepreneurs often face systemic barriers, including limited access to networks and venture capital funding. EIN-based credit provides a practical solution by offering a financial identity based purely on the business’s performance, helping to reduce the impact of bias in lending decisions.

The Role of PAYDEX and FICO SBSS

Two essential tools in the EIN-based credit landscape are PAYDEX, a credit scoring system from Dun & Bradstreet, and FICO Small Business Scoring Service (SBSS), which incorporates both personal and business financial data. These scores are instrumental in determining a business’s creditworthiness and the likelihood of securing funding or favorable credit terms.

Understanding PAYDEX: A Key to Vendor Credit

PAYDEX is a business credit score created by Dun & Bradstreet (D&B). It is designed to measure a business’s ability to pay its bills on time, using a scale that ranges from 0 to 100. A higher PAYDEX score reflects timely payments, with a score of 100 indicating that a company consistently pays its invoices 30 days in advance of the due date.

How PAYDEX is Calculated

PAYDEX scores are calculated based on payment histories reported by suppliers, known as tradelines. Larger transactions carry more weight in the calculation, so paying significant vendors on time can have a more substantial positive impact on the score. To begin building a PAYDEX score, a business must first register for a D-U-N-S Number, which allows D&B to track its financial activities and assign a credit score based on its payment behavior.

Importance of PAYDEX

For businesses seeking trade credit, a high PAYDEX score is crucial. Suppliers, vendors, and even lenders often look at this score to assess a company’s creditworthiness. A PAYDEX score above 80 is typically required to secure favorable terms, such as net 30 or net 60-day payment plans, and it reflects the business’s reliability in meeting its financial obligations.

Improving a PAYDEX Score

To improve a PAYDEX score, businesses should:

• Ensure timely payments: The most critical factor in a PAYDEX score is payment history. Paying invoices early can lead to a perfect score of 100, while consistently paying on time helps maintain a high score.

• Maintain multiple tradelines: Businesses should aim to have at least three active tradelines to establish a strong credit history.

• Work with vendors who report to credit bureaus: Not all vendors report payment histories to D&B, so it’s important to build relationships with those who do. This can significantly enhance a business’s credit profile.

FICO SBSS: Assessing Comprehensive Creditworthiness

FICO Small Business Scoring Service (SBSS) is a widely used credit scoring model that evaluates the creditworthiness of small businesses. The SBSS score ranges from 0 to 300, with a higher score indicating stronger creditworthiness. Unlike PAYDEX, which focuses solely on payment history, SBSS incorporates both the business’s and the owner’s personal financial data, providing a more comprehensive assessment.

How FICO SBSS Works

The FICO SBSS score integrates several factors, including:

• The owner’s personal credit score

• The business’s financial data, such as revenue and assets

• The duration of business operations

Many lenders, especially those offering Small Business Administration (SBA) loans, rely on SBSS to pre-screen applicants. A score of 140 or higher is often required to qualify for SBA-backed loans. This hybrid approach helps lenders get a fuller picture of a business's financial health, making it easier to assess risk and approve loans.

Improving FICO SBSS Scores

To improve a business’s FICO SBSS score, entrepreneurs should focus on both their personal and business financial health. Key strategies include:

• Maintaining a strong personal credit score: Since SBSS takes personal credit into account, it is important for business owners to keep their personal credit in good standing.

• Building business credit: Consistently paying bills on time, managing credit utilization, and maintaining accurate financial records will improve both business and SBSS scores.

The Equalizing Effect of EIN-Based Credit Systems

EIN-based business credit plays a critical role in leveling the financial playing field for new startups, especially those led by minority and underrepresented entrepreneurs. Traditional lending practices have long shown disparities in access to credit based on race, gender and ethnicity. 

A report from the Federal Reserve’s 2021 Report on Firms Owned by People of Color highlights that minority-owned businesses, despite being equally willing to apply for credit, receive significantly less funding compared to their white counterparts. 

These inequities underscore the importance of alternative financial solutions like EIN-based credit.

How EIN-Based Credit Helps

EIN-based business credit helps mitigate these disparities by enabling startups to create a financial identity independent of their owners’ personal credit profiles. This can be especially beneficial for entrepreneurs who may have faced systemic financial challenges or have lower personal credit scores due to historical inequities. 

A strong PAYDEX or SBSS score can demonstrate the financial health and reliability of the business itself, making it easier to secure loans, credit lines and favorable terms from suppliers.

Long-Term Benefits for Startups

By leveraging EIN-based credit, startups can:

• Separate personal and business finances: This reduces the risk of personal financial hardship if the business encounters challenges.

• Build a robust business credit profile: Over time, maintaining a strong business credit score can lead to better financing opportunities, higher loan limits and lower interest rates.

• Increase credibility with lenders and investors: A business with a high credit score is viewed as more trustworthy, which can lead to more opportunities for funding and partnerships.

Strategies for Building and Maintaining Business Credit

Building a strong business credit profile is essential for long-term financial health. Here are some key strategies for startups to establish and improve their business credit:

1. Establish Your Business as a Separate Legal EntityRegistering as a Limited Liability Company (LLC) or a corporation is the first step in creating a clear distinction between personal and business finances. This formal structure is required to start building business credit.

2. Open Business Bank Accounts and Credit LinesKeep all business transactions separate from personal ones by using business bank accounts and applying for business credit cards. This helps establish a clear financial trail that can contribute to your business credit score.

3. Pay Bills on Time (or Early)Payment history is the most critical factor in determining your PAYDEX score. Consistently paying bills on time, or even early, will positively impact your score and help you build a solid business credit profile.

4. Work with Vendors Who Report to Credit BureausNot all vendors report payment histories to credit bureaus, so it is important to work with those who do. These relationships can help you build a comprehensive business credit history.

5. Regularly Monitor Your Credit Scores Regularly checking your PAYDEX, SBSS and other business credit scores allows you to monitor your progress and address any issues before they negatively affect your credit profile.

Challenges and Considerations for Underrepresented Entrepreneurs

While EIN-based credit systems present significant opportunities for startups, particularly for minority-owned businesses, challenges remain. Underrepresented entrepreneurs continue to face systemic barriers, including:

• Investor bias: Founders from underrepresented backgrounds often face bias from investors, which can affect their ability to secure funding.

• Networking limitations: Many minority entrepreneurs lack access to the same networks as their white counterparts, limiting their exposure to potential investors and financial resources.

• Reporting limitations: Many vendors do not report positive payment histories to business credit bureaus, making it difficult for businesses to build a strong credit profile.

Addressing these challenges requires ongoing efforts from both entrepreneurs and the broader business community to create more equitable financial opportunities.

The Path Forward for Startups

EIN-based business credit offers a powerful tool for startups, particularly for those led by underrepresented founders, to establish credibility, access funding, and grow their businesses. 

By leveraging systems like PAYDEX and FICO SBSS, entrepreneurs can build a strong credit profile that is independent of personal credit, ultimately increasing their chances of securing favorable financial terms and investment opportunities.

For any startup looking to navigate the complexities of business credit, understanding how to build and maintain an EIN-based credit profile is essential. 

As we move toward a more inclusive entrepreneurial ecosystem, EIN-based credit systems could play a pivotal role in bridging the funding gap and promoting innovation across diverse demographic groups.

Expert Insight

EIN-based business credit provides a viable alternative to traditional lending methods, but many entrepreneurs are unaware of its potential. 

According to small business finance expert Ben Yoskovitz, building business credit through systems like PAYDEX and FICO SBSS could revolutionize credit access for startups. 

However, the existing financial institutions may not fully embrace this shift, as it disrupts conventional lending models where personal credit is often a key factor in loan approvals. By educating entrepreneurs on how to effectively build EIN-based credit profiles, we can pave the way for a more equitable business landscape, especially for underrepresented founders.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/benyoskovitz/

10 FAQs on EIN-Based Business Credit

1. What is EIN-based business credit and how does it work? EIN-based business credit allows a startup to build a separate credit profile for the business using an Employer Identification Number (EIN). This profile is independent of the owner's personal credit and is established through payment histories and relationships with vendors and suppliers.

2. How can startups build business credit using PAYDEX? Startups can build business credit by registering for a D-U-N-S number through Dun & Bradstreet, paying vendors on time or early, and maintaining multiple tradelines to ensure comprehensive reporting, which will contribute to a high PAYDEX score.

3. What is a good PAYDEX score for small businesses? A PAYDEX score of 80 or higher is considered good for small businesses. This score indicates that the business consistently pays its vendors on time, enhancing its credibility with lenders and suppliers.

4. How does the FICO SBSS score impact startup loan applications? The FICO SBSS score is crucial for startups applying for loans, especially SBA loans. A minimum score of 140 is often required for loan approval, and the score takes into account both the business's financial health and the owner's personal credit.

5. Why is EIN-based business credit an equalizer for startups? EIN-based credit separates business financials from personal credit, allowing startups—especially those from underrepresented backgrounds—to build creditworthiness based on the business's performance rather than personal financial history.

6. What are the key differences between PAYDEX and FICO SBSS? PAYDEX is a score that focuses solely on a business's payment history with vendors and suppliers, while FICO SBSS incorporates both personal and business financial data to assess overall creditworthiness for small business loan approval.

7. Can startups with poor personal credit still build strong business credit? Yes, startups can build strong business credit through EIN-based systems like PAYDEX, even if the owner has poor personal credit, as long as the business consistently pays its bills on time and maintains good relationships with reporting vendors.

8. How long does it take to build a strong EIN-based business credit profile? Building a strong business credit profile can take anywhere from 6 months to 2 years, depending on how quickly a business establishes tradelines, maintains timely payments and works with vendors who report to credit bureaus.

9. What challenges do minority-owned startups face with EIN-based credit? Minority-owned startups often face challenges such as limited vendor reporting and systemic biases. However, using EIN-based credit systems like PAYDEX and FICO SBSS can help overcome some barriers by allowing businesses to establish their own creditworthiness.

10. What are the steps to improve a startup's FICO SBSS score? To improve an FICO SBSS score, startups should maintain strong personal credit, ensure that their business is financially healthy with low credit utilization and establish a reliable payment history with multiple tradelines.

Want to easily manage your startup’s finances and track your business credit in real-time? Download the Spartan Café App today to take control of your business credit profile and gain insights that can help you build a stronger, more credible financial foundation.

References

1. American Business Survey Report on Minority-Owned Businesseshttps://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/abs.html

2. Federal Reserve Report on Firms Owned by People of Colorhttps://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2021-november-small-business-credit-survey-firms-owned-by-people-of-color.htm

3. Forbes - Challenges Faced by Minority Entrepreneurshttps://www.forbes.com/sites/bizcouncil/2021/06/14/addressing-the-challenges-minority-entrepreneurs-face-in-the-tech-startup-space/

4. Dun & Bradstreet PAYDEX Score Guidehttps://www.dnb.com/utility-pages/what-is-a-paydex-score.html

5. FICO SBSS Scoring Model for SBA Loanshttps://www.sba.gov/article/2018/dec/03/understanding-sba-fico-sbss-credit-score

Why Download the Spartan Café App?

The Spartan Café App is not just another business tool—it’s a comprehensive platform designed to support entrepreneurs at every stage of their journey. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to scale your business, the app offers everything you need to succeed:

• Educational Resources: Access to courses, articles, and expert advice on business funding, credit building, and entrepreneurship.

• Networking Opportunities: Connect with like-minded entrepreneurs, mentors, and industry experts who can help guide your journey.

• Financial Tools: Manage your finances, plan your funding strategy, and track your progress with built-in financial tools.

• Motivational Content: Stay inspired and focused with daily motivational quotes, success stories, and practical tips.

Available on both iOS and Android, the Spartan Café App is your go-to resource for turning dreams into reality. Don’t wait—download it today and start your journey toward success!